Advertisement

New Year in Arizona Brings More Anti-Latino Laws

7:31 am By Maegan La Mala · arizona|Culture|Education

2 Jan 2011

In the Show Me Your Papers state of Arizona, ringing in the new year means that bells won’t be ringing to start Ethnic Studies classes in the state since effective yesterday HB2281 bans them.

The official reasoning behind the ban is to prevent courses that “promote the overthrow of the U.S. government, are designed primarily for students of a particular ethnic group or advocate ethnic solidarity “instead of the treatment of pupils as individuals.” But really what the ban does in precisely the opposite. It codifies the normalization of whiteness with furthers the “othering” of everything else. It socializes young people into consent and acceptance of “American” culture as dominant and superior, meaning everything else is inferior. HB2281 is like the changes made to textbooks in Texas but applied to the art and liberty of teaching.

HB2281, like SB1070 is also dangerous because of the groundwork it lays for other states to follow. SB1070 is creating a ripple effect across the country and HB2281 will likely follow. This is disturbing especially considering that the push for the Ethnic Studies ban really honed it’s focus on the Tuscon School District which had much success in terms of connecting with students and student success.

Like when I wrote about the law when it was first presented and later signed by Jan Brewer, I really think that there needs to be an effort now to support the educators in Arizona who are committed to teaching culturally competent and culturally honest curriculums. Just as Latinos and others rallied and continue to rally against SB1070, similar support needs to be given to administrators, educators, parents, and caregivers who will have to defy this law in order to properly educate their children.

Arizona freedom schools anyone?

Post to Twitter

14 Responses to New Year in Arizona Brings More Anti-Latino Laws

Avatar

Tweets that mention New Year in Arizona Brings More Anti-Latino Laws | VivirLatino -- Topsy.com

January 2nd, 2011 at 4:18 pm

[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by flask gordon and others. flask gordon said: RT @VivirLatino: New Year in Arizona Brings More Anti-Latino Laws | VivirLatino http://bit.ly/gbdO9m [...]

Avatar

Seane-Anna

January 2nd, 2011 at 5:48 pm

Hmmmm. Anti-Latino law? What’s so anti-Latino about wanting kids who live in America, are being educated by America, fed by America, housed by America, and healed by America to be American? Damn those evil racist Americans! Expecting American culture to be dominant in AMERICA!!!!

Of course, you open-minded, anti-racists here at VivirLatino have no problem with Mexican culture being dominant in Mexico or Brazilian culture being dominant in Brazil or, for that matter, Japanese culture being dominant in Japan. And you know what? Neither do I. Every nation has its own heritage which SHOULD be dominant within its own borders. And every immigrant has the moral obligation to assimilate into the culture of his new country. If I moved to Mexico I’d have to become Mexican; I wouldn’t expect anything else. Once you enter another country your native culture no longer applies. The Chinese put it this way, “When you enter a village, follow its customs”.

Here is real racism: it’s Latinos, in and out of the US, thinking they are and should be above the law simply because of their race. Well, you’re not. If a white immigrant like the late Hollywood director Billy Wilder had to come to America legally and learn English in order to succeed here, then SO DO LATINOS. Yep, you Latinos have to follow the same laws and live up to the same expectations that applied to Billy Wilder and millions of other white immigrants. You don’t get a pass just because you’re brown. That’s real anti-racism. Get used to it.

Avatar

Maegan La Mala

January 2nd, 2011 at 8:11 pm

Happy New Year Seane-Anne. My response to your comment comes in the form of a question. What do you say to the fact that equating the United States with “america”, when America refers to continents beyond U.S borders can be seen as more than just U.S. centric but U.S. Supremicism?

Avatar

Seane-Anna

January 2nd, 2011 at 10:55 pm

Happy New Year to you too, Maegan. Your question, though, is ridiculous and a lame attempt to avoid the points I made in my first comment here.

The word “America” refers to an individual country and to two continents, plus a small strip of land linking the two continents. I don’t know how it came to be this way, but when the word stands alone it refers to the country, my country. When speaking or writing about the continents and joining strip of land, you put the appropriate adjectives in front of the word “America”: North America, South America, and Central America. Like I said, I’m not sure how that evolved but people understand this linguistic situation and nobody confuses America the country with either of the two continents or the strip of land that joins them. Maegan, I don’t see how this amounts to US supremacism when all the other nations on the American continents have their own names that work for them and have historical validity, just like “United States of America” does. So this “US supremacism” you mentioned is a red herring.

Maegan, why don’t you just address the points that I made in my first comment? America, as a distinct, sovereign, and independent nation has a moral right to assert the supremacy of its own culture within its own borders. That is the right of every distinct, sovereign, and independent nation. You wouldn’t dispute that fact with regard to Mexico, so why would you dispute it with regard to the US?

The second point I made was that, with regard to immigration, it’s NOT racist to hold foreign Latinos to the same standards and expectations that applied to millions of WHITE immigrants in the past. If white foreigners had to enter America legally and then assimilate once here, so do Latinos. It is the demand for a different, more lenient standard for Latinos that’s the real racism. Why should Latino foreigners get a pass just because they’re brown? I’d like to know your answer to that question, Maegan.

Avatar

ladymorgue

January 2nd, 2011 at 11:22 pm

@ Seane-Anna
hey, you have a chip on your shoulder.
Arizona was a part of Mexico originally and the oldest surnames in the Southwest are Spanish surnames. America is a melting pot . Immigration is no longer limited to Western Europeans and we are more in contact with people of more diverse cultures and societies than our grandparents. You seem to define America = White/ Western Europe and that’s not the case. To me the laws are not just Anti- Latino but rather anti- anyone who is not white. Years. people complained that immigrants do not assimilate even though many do.

Avatar

Seane-Anna

January 3rd, 2011 at 12:37 am

Ladymorgue, the people who have a chip on their shoulders are the (mostly Latino) illegals and their supporters who are pissed off that they are being held accountable for breaking the law.

America is a melting pot but that doesn’t mean that it doesn’t have a right to control its borders or to assert the supremacy of its own culture within its own borders. Or, Ladymorgue, do you deny that there is an American culture? And do you deny your ignorance?

America takes in more than one million legal immigrants each year, the vast majority of whom are NON-WHITE, mostly Latin Americans and Asians. How do you explain that, Ladymorgue, if America’s immigration laws are “…anti-anyone who is not white”? I know that people like you need to believe in a hopelessly racist America, but the facts don’t support your dark vision.

The real racism in America comes from Latinos who demand to be above the law just because of their race, and from diversity liberals who think the less white America is, the better. If you really believe in equality, Ladymorgue, then you’d have no problem with Latino immigrants having to live by the same rules and expectations that applied to white immigrants in the past. So, do you believe in equality, or are you just a rank brown supremacist?

Avatar

Maegan La Mala

January 3rd, 2011 at 8:27 am

Oh well I tried and I tried without censoring and all I got was another comment filled with even more hate.

That said, Seane-Anna, I don’t know if you have the read the previous stories I posted when the bill was presented and then signed, specifially the part on how this law seemed to be targeting and seemed to be a response to a very specific program in Tuscon which dared to acknowledge, as Ladymorgue pointed out, that Arizona was part of Mexico before it was taken as part of the United States and that many families in Arizona have been in the state from the time it was part of Mexico and perhaps, for Indigenous families, predating even that.

So what is so supremacist about acknowledging that and acknowledging how Arizona came to become a U.S. state? Isn’t that just history and if we acknowledge that history then we would have to ask, who is really the foreigner?

I would also ask what is U.S culture? If the U.S. is a mixed salad (which is I dare say a better metaphor than the melting pot) than wouldn’t U.S. culture be a reflection of all the ingredients of said salad.

Avatar

Chicano future tense

January 3rd, 2011 at 2:46 pm

Maegan

“Arizona freedom schools anyone?”

SB1070 and more recently HB2281
have increased Arizona’s racial and political tensions to a flash point.

Such racist,fascistic,xenophobic laws must be opposed.

The anti-Latino,anti-immigrant racists have thrown down the gauntlet on the sand.Latinos must pick it up and fight back.

The challenge has been issued,it is time Latinos and other people of goodwill respond.

Maegan’s proposal of setting-up Arizona freedom schools is a great idea!
I would absolutely support it.

Avatar

Maegan La Mala

January 3rd, 2011 at 5:52 pm

If I had the funding to get to Arizona I would love to help set this up and teach even! But more importantly it should come from the parents and educators and even students in Arizona themselves!

Avatar

Karen

January 4th, 2011 at 4:47 pm

Re: “Damn those evil racist Americans! Expecting American culture to be dominant in AMERICA!!!! ”

I think you’re missing the point. People of Mexican and other Latino descent are also part of US culture and history. What Jan Brewer and other racists are trying to do is erase Latinos from the US history books and instill in these children the lie that their ancestors had nothing to do with the building of this country. They usually allow a section on Cesar Chavez so that the kids will think that all their ancestors have ever done is manual labor.

Frankly, I don’t know why we allow our history to be called “ethnic history.” It’s American history, and we should continue to teach it regardless of what Jan Brewer says.

Avatar

Karen

January 4th, 2011 at 5:06 pm

Re : “then you’d have no problem with Latino immigrants having to live by the same rules and expectations that applied to white immigrants in the past. ”

Instead of just focusing on Latino history I think Latino educators should focus on all US history, and teach about things like the Oklahoma Land Rush. The federal government set aside some land for Native Americans called Indian Territory. Yes, they had to set aside territory for the original inhabitants of the land.

White squatters, however, kept raiding it. They tried to build a settlement called Ewing, then another called Stillwater. After a few years the government gave up trying to battle the sqautters and trying to protect the Native Americans, so they opened up the land to settlers/squatters. The free land giveaway was called the Oklahoma Land Rush.

Avatar

Maegan La Mala

January 4th, 2011 at 9:29 pm

Well I think in all honesty the reason that courses in ethnic studies exist is to balance the whitewashing of U.S. history. But yes Karen, the point U was trying to make was that the history is American history

Avatar

Bryan J.

January 4th, 2011 at 10:47 pm

Intresting how Seane-Anna was was relatively reasonable in answering the red herring but dive bombed into rash presumptions with little foundation once the hate set in.

Avatar

Maegan La Mala

January 4th, 2011 at 10:59 pm

That is why I kind of let it flow….all true colors are revealed eventually. Happy New Year Bryan

Hola!

VivirLatino is a daily publication published by Mamita Mala Media, dedicated to featuring all the latest politics, culture, entertainment of interest to the diverse Latin@ diaspora.

About | Advertise with us | Contact | Twitter

VivirLatino on Facebook


blog advertising is good for you

blog advertising is good for you

Get our RSS Feed!