Advertisement

Why Does it Feel Like too little too late with Elected Officials and Immigration?

10:01 am By Maegan la Mamita Mala · GLBT|Immigration|Politics

4 Jun 2010

Even though I’m going to be on a panel next week on HITN to talk about NY State elections (stay tuned for details), electoral politics gross me out, especially the way I have seen paid politicians play the issue of immigration and it’s reform. The name of game is careerism, not doing what is best for the communities they were elected to represent. This is especially true for poorer immigrant communities who don’t have the power of the donation dollar behind them or even the power of the polls since they cannot vote. This makes it easy for politicos to do the politically expedient thing as opposed to the right thing. I’m not stupid, I know that’s the way the game is pero it doesn’t make it right especially when we are talking about people’s lives.

Let’s take Congressman Luis Gutierrez for example. I’m not picking on him because I am against him, or because I have a beef with him, but rather because he himself has put himself out there. No es a quitate tu pa ponerme yo. I have no interest in “doing” electoral politics if you will. My feet are firmly planted in the calle.

Recently, Gutierrez came out in favor of the Uniting American Families Act (UAFA) as part of larger Comprehensive Immigration Reform. In some ways, this a great but there are two problems. One : For months, when Gutierrez was pushing his CIRASAP Bill, the exclusion of LGBT families was a calculated move, aimed to keep the support of faith organizations. Two : most DC insiders say that comprehensive immigration reform is dead this year. So what’s the point? What’s the game? It’s pretty much the same bait and switch that is currently being played with the DREAM Act.

Say what you will about the DREAM Act (and I have over the years), but the DREAMers are feeling used by the comprehensive immigration reform movement, many of it’s advocates, and the politicians who keep telling them publicly push for CIR with a Dream Act included, while whispering that they know CIR will not happen this year.

It’s political bullshit. It’s about careers and money, as Gabriel Martinez, a DREAMer entering Day 4 of an indefinite hunger strike in front of Senator Chuck Schumer’s NYC office in Midtown Manhattan, told me the other day.

The DREAM’ers are calling Gutierrez to task. While being respectful and acknowledging the role that he has played in the greater CIR struggle, The DREAMers and their supporters are asking for Congressman Gutierrez to publicly support a stand alone DREAM Act and to do it by June 8, four days from today.

The time is now, not just for the undocumented youth who are risking their freedom and health but for the politicos and advocacy organizations to show what they really stand for, their own careers or the lives of their constituents?

Post to Twitter

5 Responses to Why Does it Feel Like too little too late with Elected Officials and Immigration?

Avatar

Tweets that mention Why Does it Feel Like too little too late with Elected Officials and Immigration? | VivirLatino -- Topsy.com

June 4th, 2010 at 10:21 am

[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Vivir Latino, anja asenjo. anja asenjo said: Because its TRUE RT @VivirLatino: Why Does it Feel Like too little too late with Elected Officials & #Immigration? http://bit.ly/aiPW0p [...]

Avatar

Why Does it Feel Like too little too late with Elected Officials and Immigration? | Latino News

June 4th, 2010 at 10:29 am

[...] From: Vivir Latino [...]

Avatar

Bryan J.

June 4th, 2010 at 12:53 pm

Unfortunately, you are right; logically, given the concrete distinction between dreamers and others(and our imm. laws to make it clear in many situations that youths’ unlawful presence is less culpable), there is no reason to make them inseparable in passing. Gabriel is gutsy here; it must take a lot of courage. But I’d implore him, if he becomes markedly ill during the hunger strike, to not go till the end.

It reminds me, quite pointedly, of Guillermo Coco Farinas, who is on his 100th day of a hunger strike. Many of his fellow dissidents have urged him to stop because he is more valuable alive than not. Granted, circumstances are different, but it’s the same premise: Gabriel believes in something, for himself and others, that is righteous, and the appearance of avenues for the achievement of this belief are shut down.

But things can change, even when the door to that change is doubled down. In the words of Fidel in reference to the IRA hunger strikers ironically, which I think is analogous to the original rosy promises of Obama words campaign-style,

” ¡TIEMBLEN LOS TIRANOS ANTE HOMBRES QUE SON CAPACES DE MORIR POR SUS IDEAS, TRAS 60 DIAS DE HUELGA DE HAMBRE! AL LADO DE ESTE EJEMPLO ¿QUE FUERON LOS TRES DIAS DE CRISTO EN EL CALVARIO, SIMBOLO DURANTE SIGLOS DEL SACRIFICIO HUMANO? ¡ES HORA DE PONER FIN, MEDIANTE LA DENUNCIA Y LA PRESION DE LA COMUNIDAD MUNDIAL, A ESA REPUGNANTE ATROCIDAD!”

Tremble Schumer, Tremble.

Avatar

Pablo

June 4th, 2010 at 11:28 pm

Most D.C. insiders only say immigration is dead this year on TV. Most D.C. insiders have known for months that CIR is coming after the recess.

Avatar

RWG

June 5th, 2010 at 3:24 pm

As to Rep. Gutierrez, I believe his CIRASAP excluded gay and lesbian couples because he made a political calculation that the support of the Catholic Bishops was more important than the votes of the GLBT community. He would rather kiss their ring than stand up for equality. Later, in the light of the continued revelations of the worldwide church child sex abuse scandal, he likely decided it may be better to distance himself from the US Bishops and support equality instead. This was a good decision to be sure, but we shall not forget his willingness to throw us under the bus first time around for short-term political advantage. In my view, there can be no compromise with evil, which the Congressman tried to do. Either you’re for equality or you’re not.

Interestingly, at his recent presser when he proclaimed his support for UAFA language to be included, it was for “any future CIR” He didn’t say he was amending his own bill. More slime.

I think the Dream act will be enacted, in one way or another, mostly because its the right thing to do. Legislators don’t want to see an endless parade of young people, who are no different than their own kids, being thrown out of the country or denied a future, because of what their parents did years before. It’s just not the American thing to do. Don’t give up on that one.

Hola!

VivirLatino is a daily publication published by Mamita Mala Media, dedicated to featuring all the latest politics, culture, entertainment of interest to the diverse Latin@ diaspora.

About | Advertise with us | Contact | Twitter

VivirLatino on Facebook


blog advertising is good for you

blog advertising is good for you

Get our RSS Feed!