7:00 am By Maegan la Mamita Mala · arizona|Immigration|Politics|Seattle
11 May 2010With so many eyes on Arizona post the passing of SB1070 in Arizona, there is less talk about the possibility for comprehensive immigration reform and the violence, both from the State and it’s residents and how they are connected.
Take for example the recent beat down by Seattle police officers caught on tape, complete with anti-Mexican slurs.
Trigger warning : the video contains violence and slurs
The fact that the man beat up in the video had nothing to do with the crime reported (a robbery with Latinos involved) is besides the point. If the police had beat up and used anti-Mexican slurs against the “criminals” would we, those who consume media feel a little better about it, think somewhere in the back of our minds “well, they had it coming”?
The point is that laws like SB1070 and the current Comprehensive Immigration Reform framework put out there by Senator biometric Chuck Schumer works from the default position that immigrants, painted broadly as Latinos, painted broadly as Mexicans are criminals. It works from the framework that we need to prove ourselves worthy of humane treatment via speaking proper English, paying fines disguised as taxes, getting to the back of the line. Resistance to this, asking for legalization and/or basic human rights is seen as ungrateful and as an unwillingness to play the political game we asked to swallow in the name of political efficiency.
I am happy to see the boycotts and the civil disobedience in response to SB1070 just as I am happy to stand on a corner of my hood with my hija just talking to my vecinos about what this means for ALL of us. Pero I am bothered by the treatment of what happened to this man in Seattle, the disrespect towards the lives of our hermanos and hijas, and the accolades paid to Democrats for moving forward on a CIR plan that takes its lead from Arpaio. I am bothered that too many being credited with leading the movement talk about all of these things as if they are separate. As if one monster isn’t feeding the others and are all being led by the same master.
The other evening walking to casa mala, I saw four NYPD officers teasing and fucking with a Latino man who was visibly drunk pero really wasn’t bothering anyone. Of the busy crowd in Corona, NY only three people stood by to watch, not saying a word, just letting the police know we were watching. Those people were another Latino man, my three year old, and myself. When the cops finally had had enough fun and sent the man on his way, the other adult witness looked at me shaking his head saying in Spanish ” they have nothing better to do than harass those who are doing nothing but surviving”.
We need more witnesses and we need to do more than survive.
VivirLatino is a daily publication published by Mamita Mala Media, dedicated to featuring all the latest politics, culture, entertainment of interest to the diverse Latin@ diaspora.
About | Advertise with us | Contact | Twitter
18 Responses to We Should Not Separate the Violence from the CIR Debate
la Macha
May 11th, 2010 at 8:19 am
makes me sick sick sick sick.
Cop Strikes Blow For Mexican Urine Lovers Everywhere | UMX | El Machete
May 11th, 2010 at 9:52 am
[...] Mala at VivirLatino offers an important political reminder that many of us constantly have to remind DC folk: The point is that laws like SB1070 and theĀ current Comprehensive Immigration Reform framework put out there by Senator biometric Chuck Schumer works from the default position that immigrants, painted broadly as Latinos, painted broadly as Mexicans are criminals. It works from the framework that we need to prove ourselves worthy of humane treatment via speaking proper English, paying fines disguised as taxes, getting to the back of the line. Resistance to this, asking for legalization and/or basic human rights is seen as ungrateful and as an unwillingness to play the political game we asked to swallow in the name of political efficiency. [...]
Chicano future tense
May 11th, 2010 at 11:32 am
I think many of us Latinos have been feeling and thinking the same thing as you describe here in your article.Seeing the news about the Seattle cops beating and taunting that Latino kid with racial slurs and insults is a sobering experience.
Such brutality is totally outrageous!One truly tragic aspect of this story is that this kind of violence occurs every day-all the time-everywhere in America.Most local city and state news reports rarely get national coverage so we most often do not get a feeling of the macro “big picture” on a national scale of the pervasive and constant pattern of violence directed against Latinos both by police authorities as well as groups and individuals carrying out hate crimes.It’s frightening and sobering to have such an ominous epiphany which unmasks the face of racist America revealing the horror and barbarity beneath the grimacing smiling mask that is racist america..
We latinos will never be free to breathe the air of freedom and live a free life in a world without racism and hate.We are all slaves of different degree with different levels of awareness…some of us see the chains and want to smash them,some of us are so deceived, confused and ignorant we see no chains at all,and some of us who have become pathological and insane wear golden chains as freedom but are still slaves in their minds..
Those of us Latinos alive today will never ever see and feel true freedom..our spiritual freedom is found in struggle and fighting back..
We fight for the freedom of our future..for our future generations..
that is why we must never give up the fight and always continue the struggle against laws like SB 1070 which creates racial profiling,police brutality,hate crimes by groups or individuals…and last but nor least STOP WAR against people of color around the world..
..there is no difference between police brutality in Seattle and US military violence in Afghanistan,Guanatanamo or everywhere else in the third world where people of color live ..it’s the same evil ..
Maegan La Mala
May 11th, 2010 at 1:12 pm
Word Chicano Future Tense, freedom comes through struggle
K
May 11th, 2010 at 8:57 pm
If the video were of a group of Latinos stomping on a prone white kid’s head, Fox News would have it on a continuous loop. The local affiliate’s refusal to report the incident (which happened just outside its door) makes me wonder how many other times they’ve had this kind of video & just haven’t deigned to broadcast it.
As it is, Det. Shane Cobane apologized only for what he said to the victim, not for the fact he stomped on his head. Eleven times he said he was sorry for his “comments,” but never once for the physical assault. The other stomper cop, Mary Lynne Woollum, hasn’t even bothered to say that much.
The Latino community in Seattle isn’t large, 6% or 7% of the population. To get justice, this incident has to be nationalized, kept in front of the whole country until these two thugs are locked up.
Maegan La Mala
May 12th, 2010 at 6:38 am
K you are absolutely right and I would add there would be calls for harsher laws against Latinos like um no se SB1070.
Are you in Seattle?
We Should Not Separate the Violence from the CIR Debate | Latino News
May 12th, 2010 at 10:39 am
[...] From: Vivir Latino [...]
Wordsmith
May 12th, 2010 at 10:45 am
Excellent point, K.
Bryan J.
May 12th, 2010 at 12:23 pm
This cop would not be apologizing but for the fact that he was caught on video. I
n light of Arizona and the other states’ enthusiastic support for similar measures, this is turning into an all-out conflict, with a great potential for the emergence of a violent struggle. I’m in regardless.
Bryan J.
May 12th, 2010 at 12:30 pm
In the same vein of the targeted minority not obtaining justice from the powers that be, I suggest you read his article by the Phoenixnewtimes on how Obama is not enough:
http://www.phoenixnewtimes.com/2009-12-10/news/the-pink-negro-president-barack-obama-the-preppy-ivy-league-lawyer-hasn-t-been-man-enough-to-confront-the-evil-personified-by-joe-arpaio-and-andrew-thomas-in-arizona
IndigenousWomyn
May 12th, 2010 at 1:26 pm
Bryan, i totally agree with the article questionning whether Obama is going to be able to be as tough as necessary in dealing with Arpaio and all the ish that’s going on. i do not, however, understand why anyone expects more out of him than any President is likely capable of. i don’t think Obama is doing enough, i think he is a few steps too far removed from his community activist beginnings. But i don’t think he should be ashamed for having an Ivy League education that he worked his ass off for. And more so, i really take issue with people cracking on a man’s manhood/macho-credentials, especially against a man of color.
Bryan J.
May 12th, 2010 at 2:35 pm
I hear ya indigenous; but those guys at phoenix times have done much more for POC in Arizona than Obama. They’ve amassed a amazing amount of damning evidence against Arpaio, Pearce, and others.
I think they are pissed because, a. they were targeted by Arpaio and b. the DOJ, controlled by Obama, is really dragging its feet on getting that monster taken care of. I mean, he still works under 287G, even with videos like this one that so clearly establish a flagrant abuse of power:
http://blogs.phoenixnewtimes.com/valleyfever/2010/02/video_clips_links_from_sheila.php
It’s downright scary, not the fact of what happened, but the absence of federal action.
IndigenousWomyn
May 12th, 2010 at 3:25 pm
Oh, okay, Bryan… i guess i missed the “context”. As long as someone is doing a lot of good work, it’s okay if they are assholes while doing it, and okay for them to perpetuate macho manhood pissing contests, etc. i mean, hey, why was i expecting them to stay ON POINT.
See, there is PLENTY for them to be pissed about, and plenty of value in what they are pointing out. It does not require them making snide comments about his manhood or his education.
Bryan J.
May 12th, 2010 at 4:28 pm
I think he deserves it, still, it wasn’t that bad of insulting. In Lschool, which I just finished with btw, there are so many people that will talk their heads off about this and that issue, but when it comes down to taking a risk, one that puts one’s own ass on the line, most will walk away.
I think that’s what Obama is doing re arizona/ immigration in general. Going after Arpaio would not be an easy task; he could, if he lost, lose a whole lot of credibility. But peoples’ lives are on the line, and I wouldn’t doubt the whole mentality of law school/elitism is what is holding him back.
IndigenousWomyn
May 12th, 2010 at 4:53 pm
Ok, Bryan, you’re missing my point. Probably quite intentionally. Is it “bad” insulting? Who cares? i’m NOT defending Obama. i’m saying i take offense to the way they frame it with insults to manhood (which only leads to posturing to “prove” manhood, and how much more “manly” could he be but to start a few more wars) and snide comments against education. i would say that no matter WHO they were talking about, no matter what the situation. It’s just shitty. Ok, people’s lives are on the line, i get that. And that needs to be spoken up about. It just doesn’t require gender-conforming/gender-questionning/machismo in order to do it.
sabina gonzalez
May 12th, 2010 at 5:22 pm
sorry for butting in, but i tend to agree with indigenouswomyn..although i see your point bryan, i’m not one to pick at someone’s every word when theyre at least trying to take action. But I think Obama IS taking action in a different realm, in a very limited one that i would never choose for myself. I think he is taking risks by being president and taking even the limited political action that he is…
Anyway, I think the perfect solution for this specific problem is someone (preferably a group of women) should meet the authors at a bar and kick their ass a litte bit, then say “oh just playing, tate it like a “man”" lol aaah, i know this comment will get me in trouble but it would be awesome…
Bryan J.
May 13th, 2010 at 3:00 pm
ha ha, sabina. Perhaps, y’all are right.
The Dangerous Game of Profiling | VivirLatino
May 14th, 2010 at 8:28 am
[...] are people expected to be shocked that there were Latino officers at the scene of the recent beatdown of a Latino by Seattle Police? As if we haven’t had enough of internalized hate and indoctrination into the blue culture [...]