Advertisement

The New Way to Make Money Off of Immigrants : Car Checkpoints

3:01 pm By Maegan la Mamita Mala · California|Immigration

25 Feb 2010

NYC isn’t a huge driving city, at least not for too many locals with access to public transportation but in other parts of the country, especially in California where driving is not just a way of life, but a way to access opportunities for work, sobriety checkpoints may be used less to protect people from drunk drivers and more as a way to generate revenue, especially when the check points are set up in immigrant communities where driving without a license is a necessity in order to survive.

The Investigative Reporting Program reviewed hundreds of pages of city financial records and police reports, and analyzed data from sobriety checkpoints during the past two years. The data revealed that police departments across the state are seizing a growing number of vehicles from unlicensed drivers. In the last fiscal year, the police seized approximately 24,000 such cars at sobriety checkpoints, up from 17,900 in 2008 and 15,700 in 2007.

Law enforcement officials say demographics play no role in determining where the police establish checkpoints. But records show that cities where Hispanics make up a majority of the population are seizing cars at three times the rate of cities with small minority populations.


While I started off the post mentioning how NYC isn’t a huge driving town, I have witnessed these checkpoints on my own block, which is a busy high traffic area that also happens to be in the middle of an immigrant community.

An investigation by the Investigative Reporting Program at UC Berkeley with California Watch has found that impounds at checkpoints in 2009 generated an estimated $40 million in towing fees and police fines, revenue that cities divide with towing firms.

Additionally, police officers received about $30 million in overtime pay for the DUI crackdowns, funded by the California Office of Traffic Safety.

Money is an important factor no doubt, but given the increase in racial profiling against Latinos and the number of cities in the U.S. signing on to programs like 287(g), the consequences of an undocumented immigrant getting caught up in one of these checkpoints can be more dire.

Additionally, the seizures appear to defy a 2005 federal appellate court ruling that the police cannot impound a car solely because the driver is unlicensed.

Via / ImmigrationProf Blog, The Modesto Bee

Post to Twitter

11 Responses to The New Way to Make Money Off of Immigrants : Car Checkpoints

Avatar

Robert

February 26th, 2010 at 7:32 am

Saying it is a necessity for a person in the United States illegally to drive does not ring true. Whatever their personal financial situation, the person broke the law by coming to this country without proper paperwork and authorization and are further breaking laws by driving without a drivers license.
AAA and other studies have shown that unlicensed drivers are involved in far more collisions resulting in serious injury or death. What about the impact unlicensed drivers have upon the honest motoring public (not even considering the financial loss due to the fact that unlicensed drivers are uninsured the vast majority of the time)?
Having a checkpoint in an area populated by many unlicensed drivers makes complete sense. If the police were going to conduct a gang or rape, auto theft, etc. task force they would be conducted in areas that have shown to be a magnet for such crimes. Valuable police time and resources would not be wasted in areas where a particular type of crime or violation is not occuring.

Avatar

Maegan La Mala

February 26th, 2010 at 7:37 am

So driving without a license because you cannot get a license is akin to a rape? Nice line you draw there

Avatar

Sabina

February 26th, 2010 at 3:53 pm

@ Robert, where are you from? I don’t know if I should laugh or cry at your comment. I sugegst you travel more and see different communitites in our country before making simplistic comments that offer no solutions. The truth is our economy wouldn’t be half what it is today if not for immigrant labor. Oh, and another suggestion: perhaps spend some time researching your family background and you might figure out (gasp) YOUR FAMILY WERE IMMIGRANTS TOO AT SOME POINT, and (double gasp) they did not bring their invitation when they arrived here. Unless you are a pure blooded native american, then you might have a case worth arguing. In any case, I appreciate my fruits and vegetables, buildings, culture, food, and all the other countless gifts of immigrant labor and identity. If the peoblem was as simple as you frame it, policymakers would have solved it already. Well, gotta go renew my license now, don’t wanna pay a late fee ;)

Avatar

noemi

February 26th, 2010 at 4:38 pm

you’re citing AAA as an authority on unlicensed drivers?

Avatar

Bryan J.

February 26th, 2010 at 5:38 pm

@ Sabina

you wrote:

“The truth is our economy wouldn’t be half what it is today if not for immigrant labor.”

There have been studies that have shown that “illegal immigration” has a neutral impact upon the U.S. economy. See the copy and pasted article here: (it’s no longer available on the arizona daily star)

http://www.latinalista.net/palabrafinal/2010/02/senate_resignations_underscore_need_to_a.html

However, other studies show that, if legalized, there would be a positive impact upon the economy.

As to the checkpoints targeting immigrants who drive without a license. Oh well, sucks, but after all, they are driving without a license and thus are liable for the fines.

Avatar

Bubbles

February 26th, 2010 at 5:54 pm

Meanwhile millionaires in California do not pay any state or federal taxes.

http://articles.latimes.com/2010/feb/24/business/la-fi-hiltzik24-2010feb24

“The McCourts, who own the Los Angeles Dodgers (so she says; he says he’s the owner and she’s not), jointly pocketed income totaling $108 million from 2004 through 2009, according to documents Jamie McCourt recently filed in the couple’s divorce case in Los Angeles County Superior Court.

On that sum, they paid zero federal and state income tax. Jamie suggests that some tax breaks will apply this year too…”

Avatar

Sabina

February 26th, 2010 at 8:54 pm

@Bryan, youre missing my point. Immigrant labor built this country. whether we’re talking about germans, the irish, eastern europeans, chinese, filipinos, mexicans, west and south africans, south asians, puerto ricans, dominicans, greeks, etc. And yes, you can find a study that validates anything, it depends on who puts the money up and how that study is conducted. But go out and talk to people around the country and you will see that the vast majority of us can be traced back to immigrants. All of whom probably worked their ass off to succeed. Where would agriculture, building trades, meat processing, to name a few, be without Mexican and central American labor? And where would healthcare (one of few growing industries be without the Latino workforce, whose parents or grandparents were immigrants? In other words, you would have to be blind not to see what immigrants do for our economy. Like I said before, if it really was in our national interest to get rid of immigrants and their labor, congress would have done it already. But you’d be surprised how effective the business lobby is in not letting that happen. They disagree with you because your argument would leave them bankrupt.
In a country where Latinos are becoming the largest majority, you may want to rethink the immigrants are dirty criminals line, if only to save you from teh eventual ass kicking.

Avatar

Sabina

February 26th, 2010 at 9:14 pm

@ Bubbles, good point. “Illegal aliens” pay more taxes through their ITIN’s than rich people. what a sad fact.

Avatar

Police Impounds » Blog Archive » The New Way to Make Money Off of Immigrants : Car Checkpoints …

February 27th, 2010 at 7:32 am

[...] ugandanews had some interesting insight onHere’s a quick over viewAn investigation by the Investigative Reporting Program at UC Berkeley with California Watch has found that impounds at checkpoints in 2009 generated an estimated $40 million in towing fees and police fines, revenue that cities divide … [...]

Avatar

Bryan J.

February 27th, 2010 at 12:19 pm

@ Sabina,

Understood. I get what you are saying. But I think that study was done by a pro-migrant group. Anyway, even if congress wanted to get rid of all illegal labor, I don’t think they could–physically impossible.

Avatar

Sabina

March 1st, 2010 at 1:40 am

They are trying. ICE is terrorizong a lot of people, and they get to be on the news acting like they’re solving something. But I really think we’re all smart enough to see that waste of time for what it is

Hola!

VivirLatino is a daily publication published by Mamita Mala Media, dedicated to featuring all the latest politics, culture, entertainment of interest to the diverse Latin@ diaspora.

About | Advertise with us | Contact | Twitter

VivirLatino on Facebook


blog advertising is good for you

blog advertising is good for you
  • Maegan La Mala: Thank you Julio! To be honest I was a little nervous. [...]
  • Ana L. Flores: I was very excited when you decided to join us. I really wanted your voice there as it would add dep [...]
  • Maegan La Mala: Hola Juliana and thanks for commenting. There is a dearth in activist/critical thinking Latino blogg [...]
  • Julio Ricardo Varela: Good for you for asking. I got goose bumps just reading this and yes, yes, yes, to it all. Thank you [...]
  • julianabritto: The sense that I get is that you might feel a little frustrated at the dearth in activist bloggers? [...]

Get our RSS Feed!