Wow. Reading this article by the Wall Street Journal about killed me. Remember the Shock Doctrine? In case you aren’t familiar, the Shock Doctrine is an argument put forth by Naomi Klien that basically asserts that governments learned from psychologists that when people are dealing with a massive “shock” (like the death of a loved one, the massive genocide of families, etc), their sense of shock is often so great that they can be convinced to do things they wouldn’t normally be convinced to do. Governments, Klien argues, have used this truth of human nature to implement increasingly strict and even violent policies against citizens that had (pre shock) vehemently stood against the policy. Think: the war on Iraq in particular, and how even as it made no sense to most of us, even normally pro-peace advocates were questioning if the war might be an necessary evil.
Many people argue that this “Shock Doctrine” is a bit hysterical. That it is giving too much credit to governments and groups in power. But–read this article by the WSJ.
For now, a coordinated rush of international humanitarian assistance is needed to save lives and support Haiti’s fledgling government. But once that process is in place, no time should be lost in encouraging Haitian officials to set ambitious goals and take charge of the country’s recovery. Psychologists tell us that the best time to change minds and mobilize people is when they have experienced a traumatic event. Once things begin to turn for the better, the incentive for substantive change will be lost.
It blatantly states right there for all to see. Use the shock doctrine. Use the shock of this horrific event against the Haitian peoples. And to me, it sounds like the author is advocating the implementation of capitalism:
In the coming weeks, Haitians might have a chance to reset expectations of what they might achieve. In the U.S., Haitian immigrants have proved industrious, inventive and politically involved—ideal qualities for a future Haitian middle class. In the homeland, Haitians should be encouraged to regard themselves as a community of problem solvers.
To get them off of welfare. And stop the thugs. And no more drug trading. Etc. Which stands as highly ironic, given that the one thing the article strongly advocates against (the return of President Aristide), is the one thing that Haitians have explicitly called for.
So the Haitians want the return of an exiled president and the U.S. wants the implementation of capitalism.
Given all the military build up in the name of “humanitarian efforts,” who do you think will win out?
10:26 am By la Macha · Haiti · 7 Comments
21 Jan 2010Call me ignorant, call me naive, call me what you will. But reading that Guantanamo is being prepared by the U.S. military to house Haitian peoples who attempt to “leave their homeland and are captured at sea,” is disturbing to me, to say the least.
About 100 tents, each capable of holding 10 people, have been erected and authorities have more than 1,000 more on hand in case waves of Haitians leave their homeland and are captured at sea, said Navy Rear Adm. Thomas Copeman.
Authorities have also has tested the latrine facilities and gathered cots and other supplies, said Copeman, the commander of the task force that runs the detention center for terrorism suspects at Guantanamo, where the U.S. holds nearly 200 men.
The Haitian migrants would be held on the opposite side of the base as the detention center, separated by some 2 1/2 miles of water across Guantanamo Bay, and would have no contact with the prisoners.
The rush to militarize every aspect of what is a humanitarian effort speaks to the ultimate unsustainability of using the military as a life sustaining resource.
That is: how can an entity whose entire structure of being is based on the *elimination* of humanity (that is: efficiently *killing the ‘enemy’*) possibly be any damn good at saving lives? It goes against the explicit mission statement of everything the military has been in the U.s. since it’s conception. The military does not save lives, it kills the enemy. Something even the most hard line pro-military personnel would be hard pressed to argue against.
It reminds me of this article (via black looks) about the reported prioritizing of military solutions to this crisis over the Haitian people’s needs:
When you store your brains in your weaponry, then every situation is a security threat. US military in Haiti, hyper-vigilant about securing emergency relief, obviously missed the central purpose – get the supplies out to save lives.
Rather than using the hundreds of thousands of dollars, if not millions of dollars, it cost to set up all these tents for the “captured” survivors of horrific trauma–the U.S. *could* be using that money to get food and water and other resources to Haitian peoples where they are at. Because, you know, people don’t leave an area when they are not starving, desperate or otherwise at their wits end.
Can the military save lives? I guess by accident, anything can manage to pull off any feat. But I’d prefer that in the future we leave less to accidents and hope. Maybe a great way to create jobs would be the formation of a “Peace Time Crisis Team” whose only job would be to respond to disasters and natural catastrophes in a way that centered “how many lives can we save” over “what is the potential security threat of this situation?”
I know, I know. Call me a dreamer.
8:52 am By la Macha · Haiti|Media|media justice · Comments Off
21 Jan 2010The following is from a really important post by Sokari at Black Looks. It’s a little bit long, but it is very very worth the time it takes to read it. Please allow a little complication into mainstream media representations of what is happening in Haiti!
There is also the increased militarisation with thousands of additional UN forces and US military both of whom have a record of brutality in Haiti, and which can only intensify the suffering already being experienced. Again and again I spoke with women of all ages who reported acts of violence by the security forces, against them personally or their fathers, husbands and sons which has left them in even greater poverty. One of the most common themes I met with was the demand for the return of President Bertrand Aristide – the only Haitian leader to have to have been freely elected and who worked on behalf of the poor but was constantly undermined by the US and eventually removed with their consent.
What we are witnessing is an invasion of battalions of military personal, journalists and mega aid agencies which can often bring with them additional problems due to insensitivity, preconceived ideas of the country and a lack of gender analysis. See the Red Cross in Katrina and Christian Aid’s previous record in Haiti As one twitter asked – who is feeding them and on what? How much of the resources are they eating up? How much of their needs are preventing urgent medical equipment and food reaching the Haitian people? And all this so they can report that people are “scavenging” and “looting”, gorge on people’s misery. Write about the need to protect food from hungry people and hospitals from the wounded. A disgusting shameful spectacle – the real long term disaster is the one being set in place by yet more cultures of violence and greed.
7:34 pm By la Macha · Haiti|Women · 3 Comments
20 Jan 2010I just got the following in a email off a listserve that has spent a lot of time wondering how to help women’s groups in Haiti that are run by Haitian women. As these rescue efforts unfold, so much of the money to help is going to NGO’s (Non Government Organizations)–and Haiti especially has a long unfortunate history of being fairly screwed over by NGOs. If the entire population is not being helped by a NGO–then sexism, misogyny and other forms of violence and power often make women the *least* helped.
I don’t know any of these organizations–so please be sure to do your own research before you donate! But the way I figure it, donating money to an NGO has just about as much chance as helping actual affected people as a shit on the ground organization does. So I’d rather donate to a potentially shit on the ground organization on the more than likely chance that it really is an awesome org.
Women’s Groups in Haiti
1. Dwa Fanm (means Women’s Rights in Creole)http://www.dwafanm.org/
2. Fonkoze
http://www.fonkoze.org/
Recent GFW Grantee Partners in Haiti
3. Fondation TOYA [TOYA Foundation], Cité Soleil, Port-au-Prince, Haiti
Fondation TOYA works to raise the standard of living throughout the slum area of Cité Soleil through the empowerment of young women in the community. The group promotes women’s entrepreneurship by implementing a micro-finance structure that facilitates access to credit for women in the informal sector. The program focuses on young women who are unemployed and/or are heads of household who live in situations of socio-economic vulnerability. It allows the young women to reach financial independence, take charge of their lives, and also helps them to access health services.4. Association Femmes Soleil D’Haiti [Sun Women’s Association of Haiti], Cap-Haitien, Haiti.
AFASDA was formed in the wake of the three-year coup in Haiti (1991-1994), because as the group states, “after the bloody coup…it was repression. No one could move. It was said that women couldn’t remain with their arms crossed. It was necessary to do something. We began with a little seed of reflection and that’s what became AFASDA.” A grassroots group, AFASDA works to advance women’s rights through programs such as organizing for potable water and creating educational opportunities for street children and rural women.5. Mouvman Peyizan Papay/Fanm MPP (Women of the Peasant Movement of Papay), Pètion Ville, Haiti.
Emerging from the Peasant Movement of Papay (MPP), Fanm MPP was created in 1980 to “concentrate on understanding women’s unique development needs, advancing women’s rights and empowering women to participate in their own development.” A broad-based organization with several focus areas, the group is currently applying GFW funding to its “Engaging Women in Holistic Health and Environmental Protection” project. Through this project, the group teaches women to install family and community composting latrines and family cisterns so families have clean water for household use, and to plant fruit trees, vegetables and legumes for family consumption. The project also includes training in and implementation of organic agriculture and environmental conservation methods, and education in nutrition and the use of medicinal plants.6. Organisation Femmes Victimes de Solino [Organization of Women Victims of Solino] (OFVS), Solino, Haiti
OFVS works with women in the slum of Solino who have suffered violence and loss of earning capacity as a result of the social unrest in the area resulting from the proliferation of armed gangs. The majority of the group’s members are single mothers, with 90 percent having been directly or indirectly affected by violence. Many of the women had previously run small businesses that allowed them to support their families; but as a result of the local violence have lost their businesses, if not their families and their homes. OFSV notes, “The majority of the women have lost all their business activities, and were forced to pay a ransom daily to the heads of gangs that took over the area so as not to be attacked again…the women have been victims of theft, burglary, and rape.” OFVS’ programs provide counseling to survivors of violence, financial aid to restart businesses, and legal aid to seek redress for the crimes committed against them. focus on strengthening the decision-making capacity of women in Solino as well as help them to develop their self-confidence.7. Kodinasyon Solidarité Fanm Djanm Sid, KOSOFADS [Dynamic Women of the South Solidarity Network] (KOSOFADS) Les Cayes, Haiti
KOSOFADS emerged to promote women’s economic independence, access to health care, and the eradication of domestic violence. The association brings poor women together in workshops, during which participants are encouraged to both discuss violations of women’s rights in their communities as well as devise strategies to resolve such abuse. KOSOFADS also produces radio and television programs that air in Haiti and focus on various issues related to women’s rights.
7:06 pm By la Macha · race|Sports · 6 Comments
20 Jan 2010Well, I can’t say I was surprised to read the following news over at Think Progress. Apparently, there’s a whole bunch of white folks that don’t like Teh Crotch Grabbing Gun Toting Basketball Playing Colored Boy. So they started up a basketball league that is officially designated “whites only.” Yes, I’m serious. To play in the league, you must have two “Caucasian” parents and be a *natural born* citizen (not *legal*). Because these white folks were smart enough to realize that there is such a thing as white Latinos.
From Think Progress:
A new professional basketball league called the All-American Basketball Alliance (AABA) sent out a press release on Sunday saying that it intends to start its inaugural season in June, with teams in 12 U.S. cities. However, the AABA is different from other sports leagues because only players who are “natural born United States citizens with both parents of Caucasian race are eligible to play in the league.” AABA commissioner Don “Moose” Lewis insists that he’s not racist, but he just wants to get away from the “street-ball” played by “people of color” and back to “fundamental basketball.” Lewis cited the recent incidents of bad behavior by NBA players, implying that such actions would never happen with white players.
Because, you know–you can’t make RULES that state “no fucking street ball.” No, you have to attribute basketball playing STYLES to a genetic/biological trait.
Sigh. Sometimes dealing with the news is just more than any human being could possibly bear.
10:14 am By Maegan la Mamita Mala · arizona|Events|Immigration|Justice · 4 Comments
20 Jan 2010In Phoenix, Arizona on Saturday, thousands of people, including families with children, took to the streets, marching 3 miles, to reclaim their community against the racist and anti-migrant policing policies of Sheriff Joe Arpaio.
Jackie Mahendra of America’s Voice shared these images.
10:08 am By BiancaLaureano · Books|children|Education|Haiti|history|Media · 1 Comment
20 Jan 2010Have you considered how you are talking with the children and youth around you about Haiti? Are you looking to read books written by Haitian authors*? Then this information is for you! My homegirl Aiesha, media maker and creator behind Super Hussy Media, sent this link to amazing age-appropriate resources (for all ages) for those people who are instructors/educators or parents/mentors who seek to learn how to teach about Haiti. There are also great resources for self-education regarding Haiti.
If you are a professor I encourage you, and echo Prof. Susurro, to consider doing a Teach In regarding Haiti. Here’s an example of one going on in NYC at the Brecht Forum.
*Shameless plug for my NYC Caribbean book club called Date With A Book. If you are seeking authors I encourage you to check out the books we have read and are going to read or contact the creator Marcia directly. Tell her you found out about the book club from me!
7:32 am By Maegan la Mamita Mala · Events|New York City · 2 Comments
20 Jan 20109:24 pm By BiancaLaureano · Music · 2 Comments
19 Jan 2010I follow Kathy “Crafty Chica” Cano-Murillo on twitter (and you should too because she creates amazing things that are affordable like this love shrine!) and she sent a link to Julieta Venegas‘ new song posted at the site Guanabee. Julieta is one of those artists that takes instruments I often associate with UKish areas and exploration and conquest (i.e. the accordion) and reclaims/uses them in ways that I begin to love.
I saw her last summer in NYC and she is super high energy. Que piensas sobre this cancion?
VivirLatino is a daily publication published by Mamita Mala Media, dedicated to featuring all the latest politics, culture, entertainment of interest to the diverse Latin@ diaspora.
About | Advertise with us | Contact | Twitter