Advertisement

Latino in America: the Boot Strap story

8:00 pm By la Macha · Media| media justice

21 Oct 2009

As you watch the Latino in America tonight, I thought you might enjoy this preview/critique of the show from Color Lines.

Take the story of Cindy Garcia. Having once ditched high school classes, Cindy is now trying to avoid becoming one of the 70 percent of students who don’t graduate from her Los Angeles high school. Although the school board president admits that a school meant to handle 1,500 students actually serves 4,800 students, CNN anchor Soledad O’Brien focuses on Cindy’s real challenge: her family responsibilities. She has a mom who needs her to translate and help at the family store and a young niece and baby brother to take care of. When she ends up pregnant, we know now presumably what Cindy’s real hardship will be.

What’s going to help Cindy finish high school?

O’Brien could have suggested an overhaul of the education system. She could have analyzed the impact of the more recent and severe budget cuts for students. She could have examined why Cindy’s stepfather is in jail (prison industrial complex anyone?) or what the state of reproductive health education is at Cindy’s school, where a number of Latina girls are facing unplanned pregnancies.

But O’Brien skipped these questions and the real world solutions.

We’re told instead is that what Cindy needs to make it is grit, focus, and hard work. In short: her own bootstraps.

6 Responses to Latino in America: the Boot Strap story

Avatar

Oldine

October 22nd, 2009 at 12:57 am

Latino in America! Very very informative. Where do the black hispanics fit in. That group (latinos of dark complexion) is painfully absent.

Avatar

This Latina in the Americas Skipped CNN’s Latino in America. Y Tu? | VivirLatino

October 22nd, 2009 at 6:14 am

[...] CNN refuses to accept any responsibility for who it puts on the air and thinks it can give us tired old stereotypes and tired old white [...]

Avatar

Sarah

October 22nd, 2009 at 9:30 am

Overhaul of the education system? We can’t even get our healthcare and immigration system reformed, how can we realistically believe that education reform will take place had O’Brien suggested it was needed? Given it was a four hour documentary produced by CNN, perhaps O’Brien focused on what she could. And perhaps for CNN they saw this initial documentary as an opportunity to start getting people to look at the man issues so many Hispanics face in America. I don’t think there are any other news outlets focusing on us, not even the Spanish language ones, who if they were smart, would issue their own special to showcase a real indepth report on us. Also, perhaps they would find more success stories than ones we saw last night.

Avatar

la Macha

October 22nd, 2009 at 1:19 pm

good point sarah–i think that there ARE some media outlets covering latinos in a more complex way (see our post about the bill moyers special as an example)–but mainstream media sure isn’t, and i think we’re more than likely not going to see that complexity making on CNN any time soon. I agree with the quoted link a LOT–I am SO sick of the “good immigrant” narrative–because i think it ultimately hurts our communities (how many of our people are killing themselves through work?)–and I think it wouldn’t have taken that much to let the viewers know just small things like “how underfunded education systems are especially in latino populated regions”–but, i also recognize that soledad o’brien can’t do everything with a four hour corporate broadcast either. I give her props for putting it out there, and I think you’re right–let’s start talking. But it’s also disappointing because if we’re going to start talking, we need those simple facts–like how grossly underfunded our communities are.

Avatar

Karen

October 23rd, 2009 at 2:00 pm

Sorry, but O”Brien had more than enough time to mention underfunded schools. She didn’t put these segments in any political, historical or economic context because it would have offended white people.

Nobody mentions why so many immigrants have come here from Mexico and other parts of Latin America in the last 20 years. Ever heard of NAFTA? Massive immigration was supposed to happen under NAFTA. That was the economic plan. But since the political system has not caught up to the economic reality, the immigrants are criminalized and called “alien.” O’Brien didn’t address any of this.

And why was she making Mexicans seem “new” to the United States? Our history on this continent goes back thousands of years. How have indigenous people been treated in the last 500 years? Hmm? We’ve survived. The Spanish wanted us wiped off the face of the earth. Read their journals. It is a successs story that so many of us have survived and are thriving in this system.

Either Soledad O’Brien doesn’t know the history, or as I said, she doesn’t want to offend white people.

This Latino category isn’t real. “Latino” refers to people who were colonized by the Spanish. But Mexican history predates the Spanish invasion. People of Mexican (indigenous) descent are Americans.If you were born in the United States, you are an American, but remember, this whole hemisphere is called “America” and Mexicans are native to this hemisphere.

I don’t things will change for Mexican-Americans until we learn our history. Not the bogus “Latino” history they are trying to shove down our throats, but our indigenous history that goes back thousands of years.

Avatar

la Macha

October 24th, 2009 at 9:47 am

She didn’t put these segments in any political, historical or economic context because it would have offended white people

I think you got it, right here.

Comment Form

Hola!

VivirLatino is a daily publication published by 2 Mujeres Media, dedicated to featuring all the latest politics, culture, entertainment of interest to the diverse and influential Latino and Latina community in the U.S.

About | Advertise with us | Contact | Twitter