10:19 am By Maegan la Mamita Mala · Controversia| Media| Newspapers| Obama| Politics| Puerto Rico| Violence| Women| media justice| race
8 Jun 2009If the title of this post sounds ridiculous, wait to you see what it refers to.
The above is an editorial cartoon circulated by Creators’ Syndicate that appeared in The Oklahoman’s Tuesday editions. It depicts President Obama’s Supreme Court Justice nominee, Sonia Sotomayor, as passive, docile human piñata, hanging from a tree while a cartoon Obama in a Mexican sombrero invites GOP elephants to take a hit.
The image is so racist and sexist in multiple ways that even some members of the GOP were offended enough to demand an apology.
“This grotesque insult requires a formal editorial apology from both Creators’ Syndicate and The Oklahoman,” said Jose Niño, a former President of the Hispanic Chamber of Commerce who, besides co-Chairing the conservative Hispanic Alliance for Prosperity Institute, has been a major fundraiser for the campaigns of President George W. Bush, Senator John McCain and other Republican candidates and conservative causes.
The image reminds me a little of how Isabel Garcia was portrayed as a piñata by John Justice. Equating any woman with a piñata likens her to a child’s party toy, willing to be beaten and broken and violated by men, including a black men. Ah talk about bringing people together. Add to the mix the history of lynchings in the United States, that yes overwhelmingly happened to African Americas but also to Latinos as well, especially Mexicans. And then we have the confusion of Latino groups, with Obama’s Mexican hat when Sotomayor is Nuyorican.
These attacks on Sotomayor must be condemned because they are an attack on Latinidad as a whole but we cannot let these attacks blind us from being critical on Sotomayor’s record.
Via / ConfirmSotomayor.org
VivirLatino is a daily publication published by 2 Mujeres Media, dedicated to featuring all the latest politics, culture, entertainment of interest to the diverse and influential Latino and Latina community in the U.S.
About | Advertise with us | Contact | Twitter
4 Responses to Sotomayor : Passive Human Piñata for Mexican Obama and GOP
Ana Celia
June 10th, 2009 at 2:47 pm
As an American of mexican descent, I find that all you emo liberals. white,latinos and latinas need to get a life, the cartoon of sotomayer is funny. it’s not sexist or racist! who cares if she is mexican or Puerto Rican or whatever she is as long as she identifies herself as a “latina”she’s fair game.
As for the string or rope,it goes on top of the head and its usually hung from a clothes line, and if you think the pinata is too docile,fix it,make it’s legs ,arms and head move! be creative! don’t let her just hang there like a bump on a log! lighten up! I would never call myself a “latina”it sounds so low class.
What part offends you most about the Sotomayor cartoon? « progress on the prairie
June 12th, 2009 at 9:38 am
[...] she’s smiling so big, so passively, about to enjoy the public [...]
UN Committee Approves Text Calling on U.S. to Expedite P.R.’s Self-Determination | VivirLatino
June 17th, 2009 at 7:30 am
[...] A catch phrase that I am seeing all over the place and is especially being used by Latino advocacy organizations asking for health care reform and or comprehensive immigration reform, is “The Time is Now” or “We Can’t Wait”. Except that as these words are written or said, there is a lot of damn waiting. 2010 marks the end of the Second International Decade for the Eradication of Colonialism, as well as more than 200 years of emancipation and independence in the rest of Latin America and yet within the stricture of the U.S. there are millions of people who may be protected by “citizenship” but in order to properly exercise all the rights of that status cannot live in their own country. Once in the United States, we get distracted by the trappings of the “American” Dream (and seriously if peeps don’t get that I am not talking about Americo Vespucci then don’t bother reading anymore) and try and pretend that we are not othered. [...]
New Sotomayor Stereotype : The Latina Housekeeper | VivirLatino
June 18th, 2009 at 11:52 am
[...] I knew we were missing a stereotype. Sotomayor has already been sexualized,objectified and dehumanized . She’s been called angry and a reverse racist. And now, yes she’ll clean up after you [...]