Advertisement

Is Immigrant Justice American?

10:41 am By Jennifer Woodard Maderazo · Immigration

23 Apr 2008


While the facts about immigrant detention are important to note, I take issue with the idea that justice and human rights is an “American” value.
First, as I have noted before, it bothers me how the word “American” has been appropriated to mean the United States and exclude Latin America, including Central and South America. This to me is a framing of America that seeks to silence a large portion of the “American” population (the “voiceless” in the MLK quote).


Getting beyond the use of language, is the historical inaccuracy of the idea of “getting back American ideals of justice”.

I’m sure quite a few Native tribes would take issue of how the United States was founded based on justice. Throw in slavery as well, and the myth of the United States gets taken down a notch further.

I understand that this framing is unpopular because it goes against what is taught in our schools and repeated over and over in the media about how we should view the U.S., but I think if any measure of justice is going to attained for anyone, we need to be real, and not just appeal to the mainstream by allowing them to keep their false idea of “America”.

Video Via / Pro Inmigrant

Post to Twitter

2 Responses to Is Immigrant Justice American?

Avatar

Julia

April 25th, 2008 at 11:12 am

I completely agree about the (mis-) use of the term “American”, never mind the denial about the ugly parts US history….completely.
But a thought: I think when terms like “American justice” are used it’s an attempt to call out the bluff of those who defend hateful/unjust policies by saying they believe in “American ideals” etc. etc. (Eg, if you really believe these good things are “American”, why aren’t you putting them into practice?)
I’ve found myself using those terms when debates get very emotional/simplistic, yet I don’t buy into a jingoistic idea of “wonderful America” (America is 3 continents to me, not one country).
Maybe I’m way off, often am, but that’s my 2 cents. I think it’s a strategy, flawed yes but sometimes effective.

Avatar

Maegan la Mala Ortiz

April 25th, 2008 at 12:21 pm

I think the flawed terminology can be used to point out the inherent problems with the idea of so-called “American ideals” sure, I just think that those doing that are in the minority and the mainstream use of the term is dangerous, especially in “liberal” circles that use it as part of their organizing rhetoric, as if going back to the way things were will make everything better when, well it was never better for a huge chunk of the population.

Hola!

VivirLatino is a daily publication published by Mamita Mala Media, dedicated to featuring all the latest politics, culture, entertainment of interest to the diverse Latin@ diaspora.

About | Advertise with us | Contact | Twitter

VivirLatino on Facebook


blog advertising is good for you

blog advertising is good for you
  • AngryLatino: Great question! One thing we need to all be very aware of is that throughout this election year, bot [...]
  • Maegan La Mala: Hi Melanie! Thank you so much for taking time to comment on this post. Thinking and hoping is what k [...]
  • Melanie Edwards - Ella Media & ModernMami.com: I'm very glad you were able to make it despite the travel issues. Your question was a wonderful one [...]
  • Maegan La Mala: Aww Thank you Vicky - so kind of you to stop by and comment. I am working on a day one post as I wri [...]
  • Vicky B., MSW (@DocSabia): I look forward to your take on the trip as a whole, your critique, and your insight! Some of my [...]

Get our RSS Feed!