Thankfully my daughter’s teacher opted not to mention Columbus Day, being observed today by some, me not included. Some relatives here from Chile had a hard time understanding why Columbus Day was the holiday here and not Dia de la Raza, celebrating the survival and resistance of indigenous Latino cultures rather than celebrating the guy who got lost and laid claim to “discovering” something that had been around for a while. Refer back to last year’s post on the subject:
…he actually didn’t discover a thing (lands inhabitated by indigenous peoples don’t need to be “discovered”) and he didn’t even actually set foot on North America proper. What he did set off was a cycle of violence that violated the land and human rights of Indigenous, Native and First Nation people across the Americas.Don’t buy what I’m selling? According an organization/coalition called Transform Columbus Day:
During Columbus’ tenure as “viceroy and governor” of the Caribbean Islands and the American mainland from 1493 until 1500, he instituted policies of slavery (encomienda) and the systematic murder and rape of the Taino population. Dominican priest, Bartolome de Las Casas was the first European historian in the Americas. He was an eyewitness and wrote in painful detail of the tortures he witnessed. In a survey conducted in 1496, he estimated that over 5 million people had been exterminated within the first three years of the Columbus rule. [Actual survey conducted in 1496 by Bartolome de Las Casas, cited in J.B. Thatcher, Christopher Columbus, Vol. 2 [Source: New York: Putnam Sons Publishers, 1903-1904), p. 348ff. cited in Churchill.] Later accounts that gloss over the horrors of the Columbus regime are the revisions of history.
See that’s not something worth celebrating in my mind.
VivirLatino is a daily publication published by 2 Mujeres Media, dedicated to featuring all the latest politics, culture, entertainment of interest to the diverse and influential Latino and Latina community in the U.S.
About | Advertise with us | Contact | Twitter
4 Responses to Columbus Day (Not) Observed
Kelly
October 8th, 2007 at 11:03 pm
I am on a teacher message board and one of the posts last week was for “cute” Columbus Day activities. Cute? In my mind, cute and Columbus don’t go together.
I was kind of perplexed by the Columbus Day sales too -
Michael Johnson
October 9th, 2007 at 11:16 am
it should not be observed at all
read Gary Jennings books, Aztec
Viva El Frente/Verde
Mario
October 9th, 2007 at 6:30 pm
Why shouldn’t there be a day dedicated to Cristobal Colon (yes, he was Spanish not Italian). Like it or not, he is the reason why people from Central and South America refer to themselves as Latinos, even though that is certainly not an accurate moniker. I am not excusing what Senor Colon did, but people have to realize that he only behaved like a man of his age, and to judge him by our standards, not only shortchanges him, it also shortchanges all of our ancestors.
The Almirante should be celebrated because thanks to him, a new and vibrant culture took shape. Was there a great deal of catharsis associated with its birth? Absolutely! Was the birth of Latin-American culture painful? You bet! However, to go around hiding our collective faces in shame when Columbus’ landing on Hispaniola is mentioned, unfairly denies the very event that eventually led to the rise of some of the world’s most vibrant cultures.
Ramón
October 11th, 2007 at 1:40 pm
Mario; I have to agree with you.
Time and again, Colón is judged outside of the historical context in which he lived. He was no different than Europeans of other nationalities and ethnicities. To lay the blame for the atrocities committed against indigenous peoples squarely on his shoulders, without scourging all of the rest of the “explorers” is naïve.
And, while del las Casas was clearly an advocate for the indigenous people, I don’t think that Africans would award him a humanitarian prize, so to my thinking, defending one group by suggesting the enslavement of another smacks of bias that puts his statistics in a questionable light. Five million is a high number to count and access – I don’t doubt the veracity of the claim in the overall genocide of South and North América, over period of time that was beyond de las Casas’ lifetime, but if people accept his claims as truth, then they’re going to accept other suspect facts as truth too, and what that does is it puts much of history on its head.
So, point the finger, equally, at ALL of the lawless Europeans, or leave Colón alone. Allowing the Anglos and their allies to have Colón and other Latins to shoulder the blame, plays right into their agenda of divide and conquer. It should be our business as Latinos to work to repair the damage that genocide, racism, slavery, and exploitation has visited on all of us. Evo Morales said that his people aren’t about revenge; we can learn from that by looking into all of our communities; black, white, Asian, Arab, Jew, indigenous, and work on our common goals.
Our Latin-Italian brothers and sisters should let go of the notion that Colón was Genoese. Colón even had correspondence with his brother, Diego, in which he stated that he wasn’t the first admiral in the family, by mentioning their uncle who had been a Catalán naval officer – something that was important to withhold from the Catholic Kings.