Advertisement

September 11 Belongs to No One, Belongs to Everyone

7:00 am By Jennifer Woodard Maderazo · Chile| New York City| Politics

11 Sep 2007

arpilleraHaving a group of Chilenos in my apartment last night reminded me again about the multiple layers behind the date September 11. Despite the United States and all the presidential hopefuls claiming ownership of the date and whoring it for multiple purposes, 9-11 belongs to no one country. But perhaps I said it best in my post from last year.

Part of the personal struggle I deal with on 9-11 is the straddling of grief and confronting the egocentrism that is United States culture. In general people in the United States have short term memory. Selectively people remember and claim dates and tragedies as if they belonged to no one else before them. 9-11 is one of those dates.

Five years ago today I was on my way to my job in the financial district of Manhattan, blocks away from the World Trade Center. A man came into the subway at one point yelling something about planes hitting the Twin Towers. As one of a trainful of jaded New Yorkers, I ignored him. As long as the subways were still running , nothing was really wrong.

Minutes later as my train approached Canal Street and the conductor announced that the train would go no further, something became apparently wrong. While underground it was unclear the extent of what was happening above. I called my mother, who worked in one of the World Trade Center towers and no one answered. I soon was trapped for hours in a dark smoke filled subway car as the Twin Towers collapsed above me, as my mother watched bodies falling from those buildings and she ran for safety. For hours she thought I was dead. For hours I thought she was dead. Between us we lost collegues but not each other. We both walked from downtown Manhattan back home to Queens.

But 9-11-01 wasn’t my first 9-11 and it wasn’t the world’s either. 10 years ago I didn’t stayed holed up in a Providencia, Santiago de Chile apartment I shared with gringo college students. I went to the Universidad de Chile to remember what happened on 9-11-73, when democratically elected Socialist president Salvador Allende was overthrown by Augusto Pinochet backed by the good ole U.S. of A.

My children, half Chilean, half Puerto Rican (which by default means United States citizens) carry these multiple tragedies in their blood line. My partner woke up this morning to watch not the numerous memorials on U.S. network television but to watch the commemoration of another fireball that was the Moneda palace. On 9-11, in different years, different buildings were on fire in different countries. Both led to secret prisons, summary arrests, murder and disapearances. Both remain linked forever by the same politics.

I mourn for all across the world who lost something/someone on September 11 regardless of the year. I mourn for all of us.

7 Responses to September 11 Belongs to No One, Belongs to Everyone

Avatar

Kelly

September 11th, 2007 at 9:31 am

Very well said!

Avatar

Mario

September 11th, 2007 at 11:19 am

You know Meagan, whereas I agree with you when you say that the US is egocentric, I get a little tired of folks claiming that the US is the epicenter of evil; what happened in Chile would not have occurred without the active complicity of many Chileans. I am by no means condoning what occurred, but I will tell you the same thing that I told someone else on a different post; you are a citizen, get up off your ass and do something about it, vote, educate, raise awareness, thank God that when the United States was founded, the Constitution was written, and that the Bill of Rights guarantees your right to assembly and free speech, but please don’t set off any bombs. Otherwise, here is another suggestion for you, leave and don’t let the door hit your ass on the way out. Let me conclude with this famous quote by Carl Schurz (1829-1906, German orator, later U.S. general and senator): “Our country right or wrong. When right, to be kept right; when wrong, to be put right.”

Avatar

Maegan la Mala Ortiz

September 11th, 2007 at 11:40 am

Mario, I don’t know how long you have been reading this blog and more specifically my writings, but I am in a very unique position as a Puerto Rican in terms of what exactly is “my country”. So even if I were to go to my country, I would be in your country. If I were to go to my country, I could not vote in the presidential election. Where would you suggest I go?

Avatar

Mario

September 11th, 2007 at 12:55 pm

Hermana, you have no idea how much I empathize with you, but as a mestizo getting it from both sides gets old. Yes, the US is egocentric, and I could add near sighted to that. No, the US is not the epicenter of evil, and the grass always looks greener on the other side of the fence. Take the step and become a full blown US citizen and do what you can to cause things to change from within.

Avatar

Sandina

September 12th, 2007 at 12:07 pm

Beautifully put, Mala! 9/11/01 was an attack vs. humanity, just like 9/11/73 was an attack vs. democracy in Chile. People from all over the world died when the Trade Towers came down, but innocent people continue to die in Iraq, Afghanistan, et al because our govt. responded to the violence with even more violence. Just like Gandhi said, “An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind.”

Avatar

Maegan la Mala Ortiz

September 12th, 2007 at 12:54 pm

Mario- I was born a U.S. citizen , as was my mother in Puerto Rico, there are no steps to take.

Avatar

Mario

September 13th, 2007 at 5:21 pm

Meagan, I understand that as someone born in Puerto Rico you have your citizenship, I also agree with you that the US is not perfect. However, I will say it again; the USA is not the epicenter of evil. Please don’t get me wrong this is not specifically aimed at you, this is aimed at anyone that is not particularly satisfied with the way our country (that would be the USA) runs, go out there and do something about it.

If you are a citizen, you can participate in the political process, at the very least vote. How many of you out there know that most of the people that vote possess a BA degree, and are at least middle class. Now for a quick pop quiz folks, most people that fall into that bracket are:
1. white
2. Latin
3. African-American
4. Asian

If your answer was white, you are correct. Now ask yourself, keeping in mind that I am not trying to slam any particular ethnicity including Caucasians, should the only Americans that participate in the decision making process be white? Am I making my point?

No, you should no be Hanoi Janes, but yes I am telling you that if you are one of those people that bitches and complains about George Bush and the rest of his cronies, and you did not at least take the time to cast your ballot, you have no one to blame but yourself and others just like you. The 2008 elections are just around the corner folks; remember this post.

Hola!

VivirLatino is a daily publication published by 2 Mujeres Media, dedicated to featuring all the latest politics, culture, entertainment of interest to the diverse and influential Latino and Latina community in the U.S.

About | Advertise with us | Contact | Twitter

  • libhomo: There are plenty of poor people in the North, but most of them aren't so fat. The real problem is t [...]
  • Maegan La Mala: Yeah Johnny Depp kind of makes me hot. I want to see this too [...]
  • runescape money: I was not refering to you. But I am sure that you have seen a lot of that at this point. [...]
  • runescape gold: Having many friends in Honduras the fear was tha Zelaya had rigged the referendum results and was go [...]
  • Laurie: Thanks for getting the word out about the reality of the situation in Honduras. The people of Hondur [...]