Advertisement

Fri02Mar2007

Mexico: If the U.S. Won't Reform Immigration, They Will

13:24 H | Topics: Immigration - Mexico

immigration.jpgSeems like Mexican Presidente Felipe Calderon is getting just as tired of waiting for U.S. immigration "reform" like the rest of us. So much so, that he's decided to push his own immigration plan and just in time to show it off for an upcoming visit by President Bush.

Calderon’s migration agency announced the first phase Tuesday, pledging improvements to 48 detention centers in response to criticism that illegal Central American migrants are denied the respect Mexico demands for its citizens in the U.S.

Calderon's plan has parts that nearly mimic the words of U.S. anti-immigrant politicians and pundits and other parts that strikingly contrast with those sentiments. For example:

“We have a porous, southern border with little control of who comes in from Central America and other regions,” acknowledged Florencio Salazar, the department’s deputy secretary of migration affairs.
Just replace Central America with Mexico and voila! You have Lou Dobbs! But Mexico is also looking to decriminalize undocumented immigrants.
Calderon also will push Mexico’s Congress to make being undocumented a civil violation, rather than a crime, Salazar said. By contrast, Republicans in the U.S. Congress have sought to treat undocumented migrants as felons.

Via / MSNBC

Related

Feedback (4) » Share your opinion

1. theCardinal ~ Friday, Mar 02 2007 | 21:43H:

This is somewhat disingenuous. After all many crossing the southern border into Mexico are just trying to make their way to the US. This has been an issue for the Americans in the past - that Mexico encourages Central American immigrants to make their way north. It is unlikely that the US will be swayed by this measure if anything this only makes things worse.

2. Rue-Mur ~ Sunday, Mar 04 2007 | 11:04H:

What something is "called" is of little importance when there is no difference in the treatment one receives. But then, on the other hand, it is interesting that a "civil violation" makes the "turn around" back to the country they came from a little (? or a LOT?) less expensive and complicated. Take the court system out of the process and it becomes an awful lot like herding cattle that have strayed into where they have no business being, back across the river into their own fields. Why have a judge make a ruling about something so simple? Why have that expense? Or the expense of confinement and feeding and medical care while awaiting a court date or serving time, afterwards, for such a terrible crime? Yes! It does make sense! Viva Mexico! Shame we don't have politicians as smart and thrifty.

3. jennifer ~ Friday, Mar 09 2007 | 08:00H:

if mexico can make a dissinefor us we have a problem. i feel what is going on with this immigration reform is wrong. they broke the law if i broke the law i have to pay my son is 13 and he asked me if it was ok the broke the law if elligals can then we can i told him no we can't. he said well why can elligal people do it but we can't

4. Yudith ~ Sunday, Mar 25 2007 | 20:43H:

Can anyone translate Jennifer's post into English or Spanish, so we can understand? What is as "dissinefor", Jennifer? By "he asked me if it was ok the broke the law if elligals can then we can i told him no we can't", do you mean that every person has to respect the law, as unfair and insane as may be? A kind of "Dura lex, sed lex"?
By the way, I would like to thank Calderon for cleaning up his own backyard before criticizing Bush. This is an example to follow. Okay, the result may not be perfect and the work far from finished yet, but who are we to throw him the first stone?
And as for Cardinal, just have the South Americans go a little more north. I know a thousand of small villages in Canada who would be glad to greet some capable workers (St -Michel -Du -Lac -Long, for example, is already busy learning spanish).

Conversation





Remember Me?

Write a comment (You can link: <a href="http://...">text</a>)

Comment Policy: Any and all outright racist, supremacist, sexist, homophobic, transphobic, fatphobic, classist, xenophobic, anti-semetic and abelist language is prohibited. Any poster using such language within a comment will be warned and the comment will be deleted. If the poster continues to use such language after being warned, they will be banned from further posting.