Advertisement

Utah Enforces It’s English Only Law

2:19 pm By Maegan La Mala · Controversia|Internet|Politics|language

16 Jun 2006

english_only.jpg Utah has a state law in its books from 2000 that makes English the official language of the state and the Governor, Jon Huntsman Jr. intends to use it. He shut down a state-owned informational website because it contained Spanish. The site, www.espanol.utah.gov, was started only a few weeks ago as a Spanish language companion to the state’s official website. The site contained information on how to access services including state health and tax services. Well seems like the English only speaking population didn’t appreciate the gesture and called the Governor’s office to complain that the website violated state law.


Michael Clara, Utah Republican Hispanic Assembly vice chairman, said:

“It’s sad that our governor’s office succumbs to these extreme views,” Clara said. “We have a governor who was an international trade ambassador. The [Church of Jesus Christ Latter-day Saints] sends missionaries all over the world. Salt Lake City is an international place.

Phyllis Sears, chairwoman of the Citizens Council on Illegal Immigration countered by saying:

Most people recognize immigration is not bad. But immigration without assimilation, both in language and in culture, could be a terrible disaster for this nation.

Because you know how Spanish speakers want to take over the United States. Don’t you? A decision on if the Web site violates state lae is expected in about two weeks. I wonder if people would have reacted the same way if the site had been translated into French? Something to make you go hmmm.

Via / Salt Lake Tribune

3 Responses to Utah Enforces It’s English Only Law

Avatar

Yudith

June 18th, 2006 at 8:44 pm

“I wonder if people would have reacted the same way if the site had been translated into French?” Of course they would. One hundred years ago, when Quebec sent half of its population to the States to work in the cotton factories, the government made sure to keep everyone from speaking their language and especially to celebrate St-Jean-Baptiste, their national holiday. Because of this, nearly no American speak French as its first language anymore. If french-speaking people were still coming in gang to work in the northern states, I am sure they would be treated the same way as the Mexicans in Utah. Something to make you wonder about the meaning of the words “melting pot”.

Avatar

Maegan la Mala

June 19th, 2006 at 9:20 am

Well most social scientists agree that the term melting pit is actually a misnmer for the way U.S. society works. Cultures are never completely absorbed but are rather mixed into pre-existing (and always changing culture). Perhaps a mixed salad is a better metaphor.

Avatar

Tenoch

June 19th, 2006 at 11:12 pm

Looking over my mixed salad, I noticed that “Utah” is not an English word. Hmmm…

Hola!

VivirLatino is a daily publication published by 2 Mujeres Media, dedicated to featuring all the latest politics, culture, entertainment of interest to the diverse and influential Latino and Latina community in the U.S.

About | Advertise with us | Contact | Twitter

VivirLatino on Facebook

  • Carlos in NC: Bryan, Like Maegan, you contruct straw men and attack them rather than address any of the substa [...]
  • Maegan La Mala: Carlos, it is only inconvenient to you because of my unwillingness to follow along with your flawed [...]
  • Maegan La Mala: No reason for the thanks....it's what should be done. It's no just crazy it's a shame and it's a sha [...]
  • Bryan J.: Carlos in NC: This original article, and the discussion with the author here, and the eventual d [...]
  • jackie: Gracias, Mala-- thanks for sharing Selvin's story with your readers. Hope folks are taking action. I [...]

Get our RSS Feed!