The Seattle Times had an interesting article yesterday about the mixed feelings and politics brought up when Latinos hire other Latinos as domestic workers. The article tackled the issue of class and how upwardly mobile Latinos now have more access to hiring household help than before. According to the article:
According to Scarborough Research, the fastest growing segment within the Latino household population over the past five years: households earning more than $100,000 a year. Hardly the income of a Karen Walker on “Will and Grace”; but at least closer to being able to hire Rosario, the TV maid.
What the article failed to address was the issue of citizenship and the power that Latinos who have residency or citizenship in the United States can have over domestic workers who do not, often leading to situations of abuse ranging from insufficient pay to near slavery conditions.
As the gap between rich and poor widens, diminishing a middle class, it’s interesting to see how Latinos on both sides of the economic spectrum deal, with themselves and with each other.
Via / The Seattle Times
VivirLatino is a daily publication published by Mamita Mala Media, dedicated to featuring all the latest politics, culture, entertainment of interest to the diverse Latin@ diaspora.
About | Advertise with us | Contact | Twitter
3 Responses to La Nanny
Daniel Perez
December 2nd, 2005 at 6:14 pm
The Seattle Times article (“Mixed Feelings: Latinos Hire Latinos”) didn’t address the issue of citizenship and power because it’s simply not relevant to the story being told, if at all.
I’ve met many members of the Latino middle class while working on my current project. I’m producing a film (Latin Voices, American Dreams, now in production) that looks at Latino life following immigration. I’ve interviewed and spent time in many middle class homes across the nation, and I’ve never seen any indication of the abuse suggested in the post, “La Nanny.” Where is there evidence for the statement that when Latinos hire Latinos it “often leads to situations of abuse ranging from insufficient pay to near slavery conditions”? I’m not saying it’s impossible, but “often”?
Most Americans believe all Latinos are of lower socioeconomic status. It’s nearly impossible to get people to believe there is a middle class at all. The point of the Seattle Times story is more Latinos are rising from modest beginnings to the point they need and can afford domestic help, but sometimes they find themselves embarrassed by the bounty of their hard work. Period.
I suggest these are not the kind of people who are likely to enslave others. But it was great to hear more Latinos are doing well. It’s good for them, the economy, and the country.
Maegan la Mala
December 2nd, 2005 at 8:32 pm
There are many stories of not just well to do Latinos but other people of color hiring other immigrants and abusing them actually. I have witnessed it personally and know other organizations are documenting such cases (http://www.caaav.org/coalitions/dwu.php).
Johnice Smith
February 14th, 2006 at 10:39 pm
I do not have a comment, but I am seeking a live-in domestic helper. I live the Bahamas and I would for them to relocate there. It is a long term position and has many benefits, No rent to pay, free food, one week paid vacation, lots of free time, very easy house to maintain please offer me some direction